PDA

View Full Version : Range Report: ASYM 75 Grain Tactical OTM



Molon
24 October 2015, 08:29
ASYM Precision Ammunition 75 grain Tactical OTM

http://www.box.net/shared/static/exe72xdp7n.jpg



Consistency is the key to manufacturing quality ammunition. This includes not only the consistency of the components used, but also the consistency in which those components are physically assembled into a loaded cartridge as well as the consistency produced from the “recipe” used to create a favorable interaction between all the components and the rifle firing the ammunition.

No manufacturer can produce ammunition that will be accurate in everyone’s rifle. Every barrel is a law unto itself and there are simply too many variables involved for a given load to shoot accurately from every rifle. What a manufacturer can do to create ammunition that shoots well from a broad spectrum of rifles, is to use quality components, find a “recipe” that works in test barrels and for several sample rifles and then produce that ammunition with the highest level of consistency possible.


The ASYM 75 grain Tactical OTM 223 Remington ammunition uses quality components. The projectile used in this load is Hornady’s 75 grain BTHP bullet with a cannelure, or the “T1C” as it is commonly referred to on-line.

http://www.box.net/shared/static/m8qriqzub2.jpg



The Hornady 75 grain BTHP projectile produces some of the best unobstructed terminal ballistics currently available from a .223 Remington load.


http://www.box.net/shared/static/tbu2vmq3kl.jpg
Courtesy of Dr. G.K. Roberts






http://www.box.net/shared/static/31gmdzoo1e.jpg
Courtesy of B&T Ammo Labs.



The Hornady 75 grain BTHP projectile is also capable of delivering excellent accuracy. The 10-shot group pictured below was fired from my Krieger barreled semi-automatic AR-15 at a distance of 100 yards using hand-loads of the Hornady 75 grain BTHP without a cannelure, or the “T1”.


http://www.box.net/shared/static/edqv78hn81.jpg


Now, we can’t expect factory-loaded ammunition to shoot nearly as accurately as a hand-load that was tuned to our own barrel. Also, the addition of a cannelure and case-mouth crimp to a match-grade bullet will have a degrading effect on accuracy; but that’s the price we pay for implementing this “anti-Murphy” technique to help prevent bullet set-back that might occur in a semi-automatic firearm. In one test that I conducted using the 77 grain Nosler Custom Competition BTHP bullet, the average extreme spread of 10-shot groups at 100 yards increased by 24% with the addition of a case-mouth crimp into the cannelure.


http://www.box.net/shared/static/745yijnrf3.jpg


The ASYM 75 grain load has a firm crimp at the case mouth. An average pressure of 112 PSI was required to effect bullet set-back using a K&M compression gauge. There is no sealant at the casemouth.


K&M compression gauge.

http://www.box.net/shared/static/z68v2k4gxx.jpg





Consistency in bullet seating depth is an important aspect of accurate ammunition. You might think that you could simply measure the cartridge overall length to assess the consistency of bullet seating depth, but this would be incorrect. Open tip match bullets are produced with the jackets drawn from the base to the meplat, (the reverse of full metal jacket bullets.) This process results in bullets that can have large variations in their lengths, however the variation is overwhelmingly in the very tip of the bullet and this is not an issue of quality control; it’s simply an artifact of producing an open tip match bullet. As an example, it’s not uncommon for Sierra 77 grain MatchKings to have variations in length of 0.010” - 0.015”, yet the MatchKings have an excellent reputation for accuracy.

The pic below shows the steps involved in drawing the copper jacket “cup” into a finished 75 grain BTHP bullet.

http://www.box.net/shared/static/cbj0zv2346.jpg
Courtesy of apb2772



The beast that produces the Hornady 75 grain BTHP bullets.

http://www.box.net/shared/static/em342aimvb.jpg
Courtesy of apb2772




The distance from the base of the bullet to the ogive is the critical dimension related to bullet seating depth and accuracy. With match-grade bullets such as the Sierra MatchKing and Hornady BTHP this dimension is extremely consistent. As an example, I measured the length of ten randomly selected Hornady 75 grain BTHP bullets. The variation from base to tip was 0.008”. Next, I measured the base to ogive dimension of those same ten bullets using Sinclair’s digital bullet comparator system. For eight of the ten bullets, the base to ogive dimension varied by only plus or minus 0.0005”, that’s five ten-thousandths of an inch. One bullet varied by plus 0.001” and another by minus 0.001”. This all shows that the proper method of determining the consistency of seated bullet depth is to measure the dimension form the base of the case to the ogive of the seated bullet.


Sinclair digital bullet comparator system.

http://www.box.net/shared/static/uj1epdobov.jpg


There are a variety of instruments available for measuring the dimension from the base of the case to the ogive of the seated bullet. One very simple, yet effective tool in this category is the RCBS Precision Mic.


http://www.box.net/shared/static/boa12emgjy.jpg


I pulled ten random rounds of the ASYM 75 grain load from the box and measured the cartridge overall length. The average OAL was 2.245” with a low value of 2.241” and a high value of 2.248” for a variation of 0.007”. Next, I measured the base of the case to seated bullet ogive dimension of those same ten cartridges using the RCBS Precision Mic. The variation was only plus or minus 0.001”.


Concentric: having a common center. Think of concentricity as a smaller circle centered within a larger circle. The amount that one circle is off-center with the other is referred to as “runout” and is usually measured in thousandths of an inch when pertaining to ammunition.

Why does all this matter? The more concentric, or the less run-out that a loaded round has, the more likely it is to shoot accurately. The bullet needs to be centered in the case neck and the case neck must be centered on the case body. This all helps the cartridge align itself in the chamber of the rifle so that the bullet has a straight shot to enter the rifling.

Seated bullet run-out of a loaded cartridge can easily be measured with a concentricity gauge. Using a NECO concentricity gauge, I measured the seated bullet run-out of the ten sample rounds of ASYM ammunition. The average seated bullet run-out was 0.004”. The spiderweb graph shown below compares the seated bullet run-out (in thousandths of an inch) of the ASYM ammunition with two other factory loads and one of my match-grade handloads.



http://www.box.net/shared/static/z9ez6tztxo.jpg




NECO concentricity gauge.

http://www.box.net/shared/static/xbc9fq7svg.jpg


The 75 grain ASYM ammunition is loaded in virgin Lake City 09 brass. The brass shows the annealing iris commonly found on military ammunition (which has no effect on performance.) The primers are neither crimped nor sealed. Mr. Chen (former owner of ASYM Precision Ammunition) had this to say about the brass:

“We uniform all the necks in a separate process before loading, to keep neck tension as consistent as possible with this brass. We inspect every piece of brass for presence of flash hole and other irregularities before loading.”



http://www.box.net/shared/static/b2oma5bo3h.jpg



For those of you who might be wondering about the circular indentations found on the caseheads of Lake City brass, they’re for the octal numbering system used at Lake City as part of the Small Caliber Ammunition Modernization Program (SCAMP). A numerical number is given to different positions around the case headstamp and the values are added together to give a number that indicates the station on which that particular cartridge case was produced.



http://www.box.net/shared/static/7sc6c4yaye.jpg




After breaking down the ten sample rounds of the ASYM 75 grain load, I weighed the deprimed and empty cases. The weights of those ten cases are shown below in grains.

92.74
92.66
92.88
92.22
92.08
93.48
92.52
93.26
92.28
93.12

The average weight is 92.72 grains with a variation of 1.4 grains and a standard deviation of 0.44 grains. The variation and standard deviation of this small sample are in-line with much larger samples of Lake City 5.56mm brass from previous years.



http://www.box.net/shared/static/3i5hgvf18u.jpg



The 75 grain ASYM load is charged with a flattened “ball powder.” The powder has a bulk density of approximately 0.989 grams per cubic centimeter, giving the cartridge a loading ratio of approximately 93%. With regard to the powders used in his ammunition, Mr. Chen said, “I worked closely with my powder supplier to get optimal powders for specific loads. I buy specific lots of the powders, in large quantity, that meet my specifications...they know what I'm looking for, and alert me to specific lots that meet the spec.” I weighed the powder charges from the ten sample cartridges with the following results in grains.

23.62
23.66
23.14
23.66
23.70
23.74
23.66
23.70
23.64
23.56

The average weight is 23.61 grains with a variation of 0.6 grains and a standard deviation of 0.16 grains.



http://www.box.net/shared/static/bz687osk1j.jpg



The sides of the individual squares in the red grid below measure 0.10”.

http://www.box.net/shared/static/ndq1cknscf.jpg



The pulled bullets from the ten sample cartridges were weighed with the following results in grains.

75.12
74.80
74.90
75.20
74.90
75.14
74.84
74.92
74.90
74.88

These bullet weights show a variation of 0.40 grains with a standard deviation of 0.13 grains. For comparison, I randomly selected 10 bullets from a box of Hornady 75 grain BTHP bullets sold as reloading components (#2279) and weighed them with the following results in grains.

75.04
75.10
75.04
74.98
75.04
75.06
75.02
75.08
75.08
75.10

This sample of the bullets sold as reloading components shows a variation in weight of 0.12 grains with a standard deviation of 0.04 grains.

The table below shows the affect that some of the variations involved in loading ammunition can have on muzzle velocity. The data was generated using Quick-Load.


http://www.box.net/shared/static/mcsodk0bge.jpg



Here’s a few more tidbits before we get to the test results. The SAAMI minimum chamber specification for the .223 Remington is 1.4636”. The ten sample cartridges of ASYM ammunition had headspace dimensions that ranged from 1.4636” to a maximum variation of minus 0.002”.



http://www.box.net/shared/static/xq6uyr4h3n.jpg




The Speer Reloading Manual states that “CCI primers provide optimum sensitivity when seated 0.003” to 0.005” below flush . . .” On eight of the ten ASYM sample cartridges, the primers were seated exactly 0.004” below flush. One primer was seated at 0.0035” below flush and another at 0.006” below flush. Mr. Chen stated that the specific primers used in his ammunition were selected because “They deliver the right brisance for reliable consistent ignition of the powder, and the correct cup thickness/hardness to stand up to higher pressures and floating firing pins. He also mentioned, "As a side note, we visually inspect every single primer for presence of priming compound, anvil, and irregularities.”

One of the things that really impressed me about the information given for this ammunition on the ASYM Precision website was the way in which the velocity data was presented. Most ammunition manufacturers only give the velocity of their ammunition as obtained from a minimum spec, 24” test barrel. While this SAAMI standard is certainly prudent, it is not very helpful for most AR-15 owners.

In addition to the 24” test barrel velocity, the ASYM Precision website also lists what I refer to as “real world” velocities; that is, velocities obtained from AR-15s with barrel lengths and chambers in common usage. The website lists velocities from well known brands of AR-15s with barrel lengths of 20”, 18”, 16”, 14.5” and 10.5”. I chronographed the ASYM 75 grain OTM load from Colt AR-15s with 20”, 16” and 14.5” barrels. The average velocity obtained from those three barrels only differed by 5 fps from the average velocity of the same barrel lengths given on the ASYM website.




http://www.box.net/shared/static/rf8ac94uas.jpg



Chronographing of the 75 grain Tactical OTM ammunition was conducted using an Oehler 35-P chronograph with “proof screen” technology. All velocities listed below are muzzle velocities as calculated from the instrumental velocities using Oehler’s Ballistic Explorer software program. All strings of fire consisted of 10 rounds each. As mentioned above, data was obtained from a Colt 14.5” M4A1 barrel, a Colt 16” 6520 barrel and a Colt 20” M16A2 barrel.


http://www.box.net/shared/static/8ohte4odvf.jpg


M4A1 barrel

http://www.box.net/shared/static/bh9yo6klc5.jpg



6520 barrel

http://www.box.net/shared/static/51fa84s0bi.jpg



M16A2 barrel

http://www.box.net/shared/static/h8daj1jhf1.jpg




http://www.box.net/shared/static/52xzjapv7i.jpg



http://www.box.net/shared/static/q3lpmdumpm.jpg




Each round was single-loaded and cycled into the chamber from a magazine fitted with a single-load follower. The bolt locked-back after each shot allowing the chamber to cool in between each shot. This technique was used to mitigate the possible influence of “chamber-soak” on velocity data. Each new shot was fired in a consistent manner after hitting the bolt release. Atmospheric conditions were monitored and recorded using a Kestrel 4000 Pocket Weather Tracker.


http://www.box.net/shared/static/lku6pn9aym.jpg


Atmospheric conditions

Temperature: 75 degrees F.
Humidity: 50%.
Barometric pressure: 29.83 inches of Hg
Elevation: 950 feet above sea level



The chronograph data is shown in the table below. The average standard deviation for the three 10-shot strings is 18 fps. For comparison, the mil-spec for U.S. M193 and M855 allows for a standard deviation of 40 fps.


http://www.box.net/shared/static/6i48lsl42g.jpg



For comparison, the ASYM 75 grain OTM load was chronographed back to back from the 20” Colt M16A2 barrel with Hornady’s .223 75 grain TAP FPD load and Hornady’s 5.56mm 75 grain TAP T2 load. The results are shown below.




http://www.box.net/shared/static/7nuaoct4rz.jpg





Accuracy Evaluation
of the
ASYM Precision Ammunition75 grain Tactical OTM


http://www.box.net/shared/static/ie4oqeyp7v.jpg



I performed an accuracy (technically, precision) evaluation of the ASYM Precision 75 grain Tactical OTM ammunition following my usual protocol. This accuracy evaluation used statistically significant shot-group sizes and every single shot in a fired group was included in the measurements. There was absolutely no use of any Group Reduction Techniques (e.g. fliers, target movement, Butterfly Shots).

The shooting set-up will be described in detail below. As many of the significant variables as was practicable were controlled for. Also, a "control group" was fired from the barrel used in the evaluation using match-grade, hand-loaded ammunition; in order to demonstrate the capability of the barrel. Pictures of shot-groups are posted for documentation.

All shooting was conducted from a concrete bench-rest from a distance of 100 yards (confirmed with a laser rangefinder.) The barrel used in the evaluation was free-floated. The free-float handguard of the rifle rested in a Sinclair Windage Benchrest with the aid of a Sinclair fore-arm adaptor, while the stock of the rifle rested in a Protektor bunny-ear rear bag. Sighting was accomplished via a Leupold VARI-X III set at 25X magnification and adjusted to be parallax-free at 100 yards. A mirage shade was attached to the objective-bell of the scope. Wind conditions on the shooting range were continuously monitored using a Wind Probe. All rounds were fired from the magazine. The set-up was very similar to that pictured below.



http://www.box.net/shared/static/xo4duzdgtp.jpg



The Wind Probe

http://www.box.net/shared/static/lkg47ptc04.jpg


The test vehicle for this evaluation was a semi-automatic AR-15 with a 24” stainless steel Krieger barrel. The barrel has a 5.56 Match chamber and a 1:7.7” twist.


http://www.box.net/shared/static/psau3igm35.jpg



Prior to firing the ASYM ammunition, I fired a 10-shot control group using match-grade hand-loads topped with Sierra 55 grain BlitzKings. That group had an extreme spread of 0.464”.



https://app.box.com/shared/static/uzajpcwtt0ie1v60zicazeuwp31c4ro0.jpg



From a distance of 100 yards, three 10-shot groups of the ASYM 75 grain ammunition were fired in a row with the resulting extreme spreads:

1.21”
1.11”
1.29”

for a 10-shot group average extreme spread of 1.20”. The three 10-shot groups were over-layed on each other to form a 30-shot composite group. The mean radius for the 30-shot composite group was 0.40”.




The smallest 10-shot group

http://www.box.net/shared/static/bu9gy0vxin.jpg





http://www.box.net/shared/static/lvc6hf6frj.jpg





The 30-shot composite group

http://www.box.net/shared/static/yhlv8lp462.jpg




The graph below shows the trajectories of the ASYM 75 grain load from various barrel lengths.

http://www.box.net/shared/static/342e04l3od.jpg




....

RiverRat
24 October 2015, 14:50
Molon,

Thanks for your continued efforts to quantify factory load performance - your testing is greatly appreciated. I would be happy to contribute to your ammo fund, if you had a mechanism for it.

Specific to this review, are the data from recently acquired rounds? ASYM developed an excellent reputation with Sten Chen at the helm but he sold the company at the end of 2014 (http://store.chencustom.com/category_s/150.htm).

Since I haven't heard as much about the company - so if these are recent loads it would be indicative of continued good performance.

Thanks again for your efforts.

Molon
24 October 2015, 15:56
Molon,

Thanks for your continued efforts to quantify factory load performance - your testing is greatly appreciated. I would be happy to contribute to your ammo fund, if you had a mechanism for it.

Specific to this review, are the data from recently acquired rounds? ASYM developed an excellent reputation with Sten Chen at the helm but he sold the company at the end of 2014 (http://store.chencustom.com/category_s/150.htm).

Since I haven't heard as much about the company - so if these are recent loads it would be indicative of continued good performance.

Thanks again for your efforts.



Your kind offer is greatly appreciated (but not necessary [:)])

The review was from prior to the sale, which I was actually not aware of, so thank-you for informing me of that.