OK so I got my fancy new Frankford Arsenal wet tumbler. The thing works like a charm. Beyond fantastic. I am now a forever wet tumbler fan. On the actual cleaning part it gets all the carbon off even down in the primer pockets. Pretty awesome stuff. Inside the cases, outside, the primer pockets... all very clean.

That said, when I used the Frankford Arsenal little sample pack all that brass came out all shiny and new looking and is STILL shiny and new looking.

I got lemi shine and Dawn dish detergent and now all my brass is pretty OD green. It tarnished in no time flat (like a day or so). It will definitely still shoot so there is no question about function... but what do I need to use to get my brass looking all shiny and good? So far the Lemi Shine+Dawn thing isn't doing it for me.

So many people swear by it so apparently I am doing something wrong. I might end up having to buy more store bought polish because this home brew stuff isn't doing the trick.

Anyone got any tips or tricks for me?